[Requests] CSW2 AP ISO (RFPC 35) Response

[Uwe Voges]

I submit these comments by order of the german "IMAGI / GDI-DE Geschäfts- und Koordinierungsstellen - Bundesamt für Kartographie und Geodäsie (BKG)" (www.imagi.de / www.gdi-de.org) which is a member of the german Arbeitskreis (working group) metadata.


PART A ------ 

1. Evaluator: Juergen Walther <juergen.walther at bkg.bund.de>

2. Submission: OGC Request 35: OpenGIS® Catalogue Services Specification
2.0.1 (with Corrigendum) - ISO Metadata Application Profile (CSW2 AP ISO):
Request for Public Comments

PART B ------ 

1. Specification Section number: [Annex D]
2. Criticality: [MAJOR]
3. Comments/justifications for changes

Summary resultset should include additional elements from the ISO19139 full set:

1. distributor

MD_Distribution_Type is overwritten in XML Encoding for SUMMARY result set, distributor (MD_Distributor) was left out. This should be included there.

2. fees

fees as part of the MD_StandardOrderProcess Type is missing. This results from no. 1. Solution see no. 1

3. medium

medium as part of the MD_DigitalTransferOptions_Type (offline/MD_Medium_PropertyType) is missing. This results from no. 1. Solution see no. 1

4. alternate title

CI_Citation_Type is overwritten in XML Encoding for SUMMARY result set, alternateTitle (CI_Citation_Type) was left out. This should be included there.as part of the CI_Citation_Type.

5. status

_MD_Identification_Type is overwritten in XML Encoding for SUMMARY result set, status was left out. This should be included there.as part of the _MD_Identification_Type.

6. dataset completeness

DQ_DataQuality_Type is overwritten in XML Encoding for SUMMARY result set, report (and there the possibility to specify the completeness) was left out. This should be included there.as part 

of the DQ_DataQuality_Type


Uwe Voges


~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

Dr. Uwe Voges
con terra - Gesellschaft für Angewandte Informationstechnologie mbH
Martin-Luther-King-Weg 24
48155 Münster
Germany
Tel. +49 (0)251 7474 402
Fax  +49 (0)251 7474 100
Web: http://www.conterra.de
Web: http://www.sdi-suite.de
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: https://mail.opengeospatial.org/mailman/private/requests/attachments/20060519/af630337/attachment.htm